New York hotels near St. Patrick's Cathedral

Cons: Everything was perfect

Cons: Too focused on being trendy. Was advertised as a 4-5 star. More like a 3-4 star No coffee makers in room.

Cons: Some of the furniture in the room was showing some wear. And the desk chair was the only chair in the room. Also, the closet was very small. Not enough space to hang our clothes and coats.

Cons: The rooms were minimalist, which is okay because you aren’t there much. However, the biggest problem we had was that our key demagnetized EVERY.SINGLE.DAY. We put it in different pockets, away from cell phones, we were very careful because it got SO ANNOYING to have to trek back to the desk from the 17th floor every time we went back to the room. Our subway cards didn’t demagnetize stored the same way. I stay in hotels frequently at all price points and have never had this consistent a problem with room access. By the end of the trip I thought I should just probably go wait in the front desk line every time I walked through the lobby just to avoid the trip back down.

Cons: Room was EXTREMELY small. Unclean (hairs in sink and on bathroom floor). Not even a small, single serve coffee machine in the room. All for $450 per night?

Cons: Nothing

Cons: Near Times Square, cleanliness and open room with large window...

Cons: The bathroom was very undesirable!! From the door not shutting all the way (sitting at the desk you could see the person sitting on the toilet because there was that much of a gap) to the shower that everyone can see your shadow in - so uncomfortable with others in the room

Cons: Service on the room was not attempted until 5:20 p.m.

Cons: The only issue that ever came up was the shower would leak a bit into the hallway floor.

Cons: The HVAC system was loud. I did not sleep well the first night because of it. The entry doors are huge and heavy. While the ADA automatic door buttons were helpful, a door man would be a nice addition to help guests in and out of the Lobby with luggage. The elevators were slow. At times there was a line to get on the elevator on main level.

Cons: The room is a little small compare to other traditional hotel but it is really clever designed to maximize the use of space. There's only one glass door between the bathroom and the outside. If you share the room with someone, your 'business' could be heard.

Cons: Long waits for the elevator

Cons: No pool they need to scrub the internet & take down every mention of having a pool. FALSE ADVERTISING & they were not apologetic at all. You google this place it lists it having a pool big mess for kids

Cons: must pay extra for in-room coffee/fridge and the wi-fi charge was way too high. Even less expensive hotels have FREE WI-FI

Cons: To get in shower was quote slippery and shower head in a weird place

Cons: The room reserved wasn't available. Reserved 2 double beds and only a king available. Also noticed the family checking I next to us had a daughter in a wheel chair and the room they had reserved wasn't available. They needed wheelchair accessible bathroom. No coffee maker in the room. Found out the day we left that all we needed to do was ask housekeeping. That information should have been provided on check in. Bedspread was dirty. Pull out couch didn't have sheets.

Cons: The room was so cold even when we turned down the air. Also the location is a little removed from the rest of the city. If you need any emergency supplies, you have to go back out to find them because the gift shop in the hotel was closed when we arrived around 5:00 pm.

Cons: The filthy bathrooms!!! They had my reservations wrong! Supposed to have 2 double rooms! Didn't have them available !very upset and the desk clerk hid from me! Wasn't even compensated for not having my rooms! Told me that booking thru these places sometimes gets messed up! Not reliable! Very disappointed in how they handled the situation! Especially since it was 2:00 in the morning!

Cons: Limited toiletries and poor cleanest. Will not stay there again.

Cons: Nothing

Cons: The room we had in the East Tower was very dated. The bathroom was terrible!

Cons: Room was old with stains on walls, pretty bare, staff was not very professional

Cons: Business lounge is dull

Cons: Small, crowded lobby; no bell boy service for luggage; only one courtesy phone in the lobby;

Cons: All of the room was fantastic except for the dated shower head. Wifi was extra which i always think is a ripoff, but other then that I loved it.

Cons: Wall were thin, we could hear entire conversations going on at all times.

Cons: Receptions staff and their behaviors with gusts who booked through third party. old rooms and furniture not as same as in the pictures in Kayak.

Cons: Too expensive for outdated rooms especially bathroom. Internet connectivity could be better and included in the price.

Cons: Parking was expensive, significantly more than it would have been if I had parked myself. The staff was not necessarily rude, but not very congenial either.

Cons: Wish the location was a bit closer to Times Square, but it's not too far...

Cons: there were gnats in the shower and when we checked out and had to leave the bags at the desk the bellman took about 20 minutes to show up and help us.

Cons: Very poor quality furniture and fixtures....beds very uncomfortable and noisy....unpleasant smell in room expecially closet (did not hang clothes in closet because of the smell) Breakfast for two $84.00 (overpriced for quality) I stayed in this hotel for three nights and will not recommend this hotel to anyone. Maybe a two star hotel????

Cons: I did not like the fact that the staff at the UN was very unprofessional. Erica the front desk manger was short winded and unprofessional, and also Victor.

Cons: Small, odly shaped rooms. Door opens into a narrow passage so you have to do a dance to get into the room. Windows are small, so feel cramped inside.

Cons: I was extremely unsatisfied with the service at the hotel. When I first arrived in my hotel room I found that the bathroom door knob was somewhat broken and the toilet handle was difficult to use making it hard to flush at times. My room was supposed to come with a coffee maker in it and there was not one. I was not upset with that fact but what did upset me was that when I called to have one delivered, I was told that one would be brought up right away. This however was not the case, I called the front desk again about 20 or so minutes later and they apologized and told me one would be sent up. Another 15 minutes went by and I was still kept waiting for the coffee maker. I called the front desk for a third time and they transferred me somewhere in the hotel where I was told that the person that was to bring the coffee went on lunch, considering I called way before noon this was very frustrating. After waiting a whole hour I finally received the coffee machine and to my surprise was just a simple keurig machine that anyone could of brought up to my room. Another issue that I faced here was upon checking out. I had called the front desk an hour and a half before it was time to check out to have them send security to my room because the safe was no longer working and to have them bring my car out of the parking garage, they asked for my ticket number which was to be given to me by the doorman at my arrival, sadly no such ticket was given to me when the doorman took my car.The front desk basically told me there was nothing they could do without the ticket number and sent my call to the doorman for him to assist me. I waited on the line and the phone just continued to ring with no response. I called back to the front desk after a period of time because I was still waiting for security to open the safe and to get the car issue settled and ended up being transferred from person to person and no one was helping me locate my car. It became evident that I would have to go to the front desk to get this handle because nothing was getting handled. At the desk they insisted that I had received a ticket, which was 100 percent false if I had received the ticket I wouldn't have been in the situation I was in. It wasn't until a manager came over and took over and helped my situation by having the doorman go an physically check the lot for my car, and when he returned I was again forced to wait at least another half an hour to get my car which I didn't quite understand why it wasn't taken out of the lot while the doorman was already over there. I really am not one to complain but when I'm paying over 500 dollars to stay at a hotel I'd expect my service to be much better than the way I was treated.

Cons: I didn't like how I was treated by the staff. I felt that they weren't very accommodating at all even though I explained numerous times that I was traveling with a guest that had a serious medical condition and that we needed to check in early. I called ahead and informed them of our request but the manager that I spoke with was very rude and dismissive. They also put us in a very unsightly room with a broken heater unit that would randomly turn on in the middle of the night. I would definitely not recommend this place to anyone.

Cons: Transportation desk clerk was very rude and the transportation requested didn't happen.

Cons: They cut my internet connection the morning I was going to check out. So that's 4 hours I was paying for internet that I didn't get. The room felt smaller than the pictures. There's a $21 facilities fee for every day.

Cons: There was a fee for the food delivery that was unknown to us. Probably should use the phrase "no-fees on the card.

Cons: Staff unfriendly and more charges at check in no free wifi as advertized and shower literally over toilet next time i go to city i will make sure to stay somewhere else

Cons: Paid for a double/double and we were given a room with 2 twin beds. 2nd day not given any hand towels or wash cloths.

Cons: Dirty room Old mattress Noisy heating cooling system Broken elevators Zero ammenities in queen room Zero wifi

Cons: Rooms are dated. AC never worked. Bathrooms are run down. I do not recommend this hotel.

Cons: Liked it all!