New Buffalo hotels

New Buffalo hotels

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for hotels in New Buffalo

New Buffalo, MI, United States
Check-in
Check-out
Compare vs KAYAK |

Good to know

Low season January
High season May
  Average price (weeknight): R2 596
  Average price (weekend night): R2 049

cheapest month to stay

34%

expected price decrease

most expensive time to stay

131%

expected price increase

(avg. price over the last 2 weeks)

Sun - Thu

(weeknight)

(avg. price over the last 2 weeks)

Fri & Sat

(weekend night)

Where to stay in New Buffalo?

Our Heatmaps tool will help you find the perfect place to stay in New Buffalo by showing you how close hotel options are to major activities

Best New Buffalo hotels

Show all
Marina Grand Resort - New Buffalo - Bedroom
1
9,1 Excellent (297 reviews)
New Buffalo Inn & Spa - New Buffalo - Building
2
9,2 Excellent (85 reviews)
R2 543+
Overview Reviews
Located in New Buffalo, New Buffalo Inn & Spa is within a 5-minute drive of Galien River County Park and New Buffalo Public Beach. Self parking (subject to charges) is available onsite.
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Very peaceful and romantic, staff was very good room was awesome!
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Room was beautiful clean and really cool. Prefect get away with my wife. We checked out the spa in site and that was great too. Staff was extremely friendly and responsive. Very relaxing and fun weekend. I would highly recommend to anyone going to this area.
8,0 Excellent
Pros: Loved the style of our unit.
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Excellent retreat to get away from it all. Close to several excellent restaurants. And close to the Indiana Dunes. Loves the bathroom, it was certainly spa worthy.
8,0 Excellent
Pros: Spacious, three-room apartment. Very clean, comfortable. Excellent bed.
The Harbor Grand - New Buffalo - Building
3
9,0 Excellent (187 reviews)
Overview Reviews
Our New Buffalo Hotel's Location is PerfectWhether you're in Harbor County for a Lake Michigan vacation or stopping along I-94 on your way to Chicago or Detroit, the Holiday Inn Express New Buffalo is the ideal hotel. The sandy beaches of Lake Michigan are just 1.5 miles away, and our quiet location off exit 1 of I-94 makes travel simple.For a stress-free vacation, our New Buffalo hotel's guests can enjoy fun in the sun at area beaches, as well as easy access to the attractions of Harbor County. Save a day to tour the Michigan wine trail and shop the many antique stores. Or, try your luck at Four Winds Casino, only 1.5 miles from our front door. Don't miss a quiet stroll along the shore of our great lake, too.Business guests traveling to Chicago or Detroit appreciate that our New Buffalo hotel has fast and easy access to I-94 at exit 1. Our quiet surroundings, business amenities like free high-speed, wireless Internet access and our meeting room are great reasons to stop in New Buffalo.No matter what brings you to Lake Michigan, our hotel's amenities are designed to pamper you. Send vacation photos with the free Internet access, or enjoy swimming in our sparkling, indoor pool year-round. There's a Fitness Center to keep up your healthy routines and a free, hot breakfast served each morning. Our cozy rooms and professional service create the perfect Michigan vacation oasis. Our New Buffalo hotel's staff is waiting to welcome you.
10,0 Excellent
Pros: I really enjoyed the free breakfast. It was better than a number of restaurants that I have frequented over the years.
Cons: The television cable operation was not really functional and the staff knew about the problem. I should be able to key in the channel from the remote but that option wasn't available. Instead, I had to scroll up and down. Annoying and a real time waster!
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Staff was wonderful! The breakfast was amazing, plentiful, and delicious I am very impressed. We will be back again!.
10,0 Excellent
Pros: It was close to the venue and easy acces to the expressway
10,0 Excellent
Pros: My husband told me if I get a survey make sure I fill it out. Everything was excellent. The room was nice&clean. A nice free breakfast. We couldn't believe how they were on top of refilling the breakfast stations. Very good service!
Cons: No.
8,8 Excellent
Pros: Honestly I would have given this hotel a 10 out of 10 but when I got the at 4 to check in I waited at the counter for about 10 min before someone came to check me in. It was empty not only in the parking lot but also in the hotel so would have been nice to get checked right in. Also the fan on the wall unit didn’t work as I sleep with a fan on and never pack one while traveling cause I know those work most of the time. Other then that the place is amazing. Very clean and even the room smelled amazing. I would recommend this hotel to everyone.
Cons: Everything
8,0 Excellent
Pros: We had a clean, comfortable room at a good price. It was very quiet, and we enjoyed making use of the facilities.
9,2 Excellent
Pros: breakfast was excellent. loved the suite and thought it was very quiet for it being such a busy area.
8,0 Excellent
Pros: the breakfast was excellent
Cons: we did not have a refrigartor or micrwave in our room
9,0 Excellent
Pros: Breakfast was excellant,cleanlinss,location.
Cons: Workers working on building at entrance.
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Was clean and morning breakfast had great choices. Beds were super comfy
Cons: No adjustable bathroom exhaust
7,5 Good
Cons: Easy access
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Super room. Very clean. Helpful staff. Comfortable bed. Linens and towels like new. Tasty breakfast with lots choices. Great location. Walked in with two bicycles and the staff didn’t blink an eye, like it happened every day. Who knows, maybe it do
Cons: All was well.
Quality Inn Near Interstate I94 - New Buffalo - Bedroom
5
8,5 Excellent (384 reviews)
Overview Reviews
The Quality Inn Near Interstate I94 hotel in New Buffalo, MI will get you rested and ready to take on your day for leisure or business. Our smoke-free hotel is close to Lake Michigan beaches, Grand Beach Golf Course, Four Winds Casino and Galien River County Park. Enjoy amenities that include free hot breakfast, free WiFi, free weekday newspaper, free coffee, a fitness center, indoor heated pool and a hot tub, guest laundry facility, valet cleaning and copy and fax services. Each comfortable guest room features a HDTV, coffee maker, hair dryer, iron and ironing board. Select rooms offer a refrigerator, microwave and desk. Also, earn rewards including free nights and gift cards with our Choice Privileges Rewards program.
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Hotel was very clean and very reasonably priced. It was a quick 5 minute shuttle to the casino. Free breakfast in the morning was an added bonus. Would definitely stay again.
Cons: Nothing
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Great location by the highway and near the casino/event center. Comfortable bed,nice and clean and very friendly,helpful staff.
Cons: Nothing. No complaints what so ever
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Great staff, great price , nice hotel . There also is a shuttle that shuttles people to and from casino .
5,0 Okay
Pros: How close it was to the places we needed to go.
Cons: The bed was horribly uncomfortable, hotel and room not the clean like most hotels. Doors by room were broke. Hot tube water looked bad.
8,3 Excellent
Pros: For the most part, it’s quiet. Small. Not crowded. It’s literally five minutes from Indiana. So if you need to use marijuana, you can do that without getting arrested (no smoking in rooms!). Staff is always nice. Helpful. Talkative. Welcoming.
Cons: I don’t like that it is right next door to a motel. I’ve never had trouble. But some men hang out outside in the evenings. I think thy are transient workers.
8,0 Excellent
Pros: loved location and price
Cons: the eggs did not taste good
7,0 Good
Cons: Someone wanting to come into room and put a calendar in book on desk. Thought that should have been done already or done by hotel staff. Person didn't show anything that they worked for hotel. Not hotels fault but other guests were very noisy at 2-3 am. Lots of pounding on the door of others rooms and doors to room slamming closed.
7,0 Good
Cons: Bed is terrible squeaking every time we move and the bed is hard .
8,0 Excellent
Pros: Location was great nice open air experience lots of light
Cons: Pool small
8,0 Excellent
Pros: Great value.
1,0 Poor
Pros: Awful experience! Online said this hotel is pet friendly And we were told it wasn't the day after we checked out Please contact me immediately t
Cons: Yes the management were extremely rude
5,0 Okay
Pros: King bed
Cons: The desk clerk had a couple of folks hanging around the front desk, and the smoking area next to the front door that gave me a creepy feeling. Perhaps they were high on weed.
Overview Reviews
The area's #1 choice for business or pleasure; At the Fairfield Inn & Suites New Buffalo, you're our #1 priority. We promise you'll be satisfied, or we'll make it right. That's our commitment to you. Ask us about The Fairfield 100% Guarantee. Minutes away from Four Winds Casino, Lake Michigan, The vineyards of Harbor Country's Wine Trail, Warren Dunes State Park, and Lighthouse Place Premium Outlet Mall. A top rated Tripadvisor Hotel with perks like our free hot breakfast served daily, free WiFi, indoor pool and spa, fitness room, and meeting space in our private board room. Enjoy Four Winds Casino at your convenience with the free shuttle. Our guest rooms offer pillow-top mattresses, flat-screen TV's and all our suites are equipped with mini-fridges & microwaves. Whether you're travelling on business or to watch a breath taking sunset on Lake Michigan, the Fairfield Inn & Suites New Buffalo will make your stay right. That's our commitment to you.
3,0 Mediocre
Pros: It was quiet
Cons: Check in was at 3. At 4 our room wasnt ready. Returned at 5-still not ready. Came back 6:45-still wasn''t ready. A rude staff member told us the washer&dryer were slow & thats the way it was. Dirty towel with makeup on it in the bathroom. Unaccept
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Clean, comfortable, decent breakfast, very short drive to the four winds casino, or you can take the free shuttle bus there and back.
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Good size rooms and shuttle to and from casino.
7,5 Good
Pros: Clean and friendly staff
Cons: N/A nothing I didn't like
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Comfortable beds
Cons: No
10,0 Excellent
Pros: It was almost perfect. Staff very friendly and helpful.
Cons: T.V. was too small for room. This was THE only complaint of our stay. Will be back.
5,0 Okay
Cons: I dislike the overpowering musty smell in the room.
9,0 Excellent
Pros: The friendliness and accommodation by the marvelous staff!
Cons: The hairdryer needs to be replaced. :(
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Very clean
Cons: The price was ok, breakfast was only served till 9:30am.
7,0 Good
Pros: Location, price
Cons: Not really
10,0 Excellent
Pros: It was very clean and quiet.
Cons: The only issue we had was when we first arrived, there was no one at the front desk after waiting for over 10miN and ringing the bell several times. Again not a big issue.
9,0 Excellent
Pros: Price and location
Cons: There was a faint mildew smell
Baymont by Wyndham New Buffalo - New Buffalo - Building
7
7,3 Good (750 reviews)
R1 090+
Overview Reviews
Thank you for choosing our Baymont Inn and Suites New Buffalo hotel. Baymont Inn and Suites is a midscale hotel brand with over 320 properties predominantly in the United States. Specializing in hometown hospitality, all Baymont hotels feature both traditional guest rooms and suites. Free guest amenities include a full continental breakfast at the Baymont Breakfast Corner, wired and wireless high-speed internet access, use of the Baymont fitness center and fresh-baked chocolate chip cookies during the evening hours. Free local shuttle.
6,0 Good
Pros: Friendly, helpful front desk staff
Cons: Food items too limited as compared to others st this rating.
9,0 Excellent
Pros: Very clean, very nice staff, pool and hot tub extremely clean and well cared for, location to Four Winds Casino and downtown New Buffalo is excellent.
Cons: Breakfast only available until 9am. Most hotels offer breakfast until 10am.
8,0 Excellent
Pros: Very nice and helpful staff. We couldn't get our TV to work, and the staff member found us a cable box and hooked it up. Ample breakfast, carb heavy.
Cons: Pool and jacuzzi were under construction
10,0 Excellent
Pros: The location is what I liked. Could go to casino because they offered a shuttle or we could visit the small town of New Buffalo and walk the lakeside.
8,0 Excellent
Pros: Bed was comfortable
Cons: Pool/hot tub was closed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
7,0 Good
Pros: A good rate
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Nice clean room and very comfortable. Shuttle service was excellent.
Cons: Need more variety on breakfast items.
1,0 Poor
Pros: Never even at breafast, got up and left!
Cons: Bugs in bed. Dog barking in room next store non-stop from 10pm to 3 am. A nightmare. Told Women at desk and she said she called the room but no answer , so the loud barking just wrnt on and on ! Crazy !
10,0 Excellent
Pros: The property in the third floor was immaculate the check in women were fabulous they were all polite and smart
Cons: Nothing
1,0 Poor
Pros: New Buffalo was a nice place
Cons: Pool was emptied of water one old man (who also served breakfast ) was the only one working on the major construction Staff was hating life Weird place I want my money back and those precious vacation days
6,0 Good
Pros: Price. $71 dollars, including tax. Room was big and...adequate.
Cons: Worst pillows I've ever had at a mid-level motel. About 18 inches square, four of them, all seemed to be stuffed with golf balls. One dingy florescent light in bathroom. Entry door lock/handle barely worked. Both lights on the sides of the bed were unplugged. Why, I have no idea.
6,0 Good
Pros: The location and the breakfast
Cons: The parking lot and walkways were extremely icy! Felt this could have been a really bad situation

Best rooms in New Buffalo

The Harbor Grand - New Buffalo - Building
1
9,0 Excellent (187 reviews)
Marina Grand Resort - New Buffalo - Bedroom
2
9,1 Excellent (297 reviews)
Overview Reviews
Our New Buffalo Hotel's Location is PerfectWhether you're in Harbor County for a Lake Michigan vacation or stopping along I-94 on your way to Chicago or Detroit, the Holiday Inn Express New Buffalo is the ideal hotel. The sandy beaches of Lake Michigan are just 1.5 miles away, and our quiet location off exit 1 of I-94 makes travel simple.For a stress-free vacation, our New Buffalo hotel's guests can enjoy fun in the sun at area beaches, as well as easy access to the attractions of Harbor County. Save a day to tour the Michigan wine trail and shop the many antique stores. Or, try your luck at Four Winds Casino, only 1.5 miles from our front door. Don't miss a quiet stroll along the shore of our great lake, too.Business guests traveling to Chicago or Detroit appreciate that our New Buffalo hotel has fast and easy access to I-94 at exit 1. Our quiet surroundings, business amenities like free high-speed, wireless Internet access and our meeting room are great reasons to stop in New Buffalo.No matter what brings you to Lake Michigan, our hotel's amenities are designed to pamper you. Send vacation photos with the free Internet access, or enjoy swimming in our sparkling, indoor pool year-round. There's a Fitness Center to keep up your healthy routines and a free, hot breakfast served each morning. Our cozy rooms and professional service create the perfect Michigan vacation oasis. Our New Buffalo hotel's staff is waiting to welcome you.
10,0 Excellent
Pros: I really enjoyed the free breakfast. It was better than a number of restaurants that I have frequented over the years.
Cons: The television cable operation was not really functional and the staff knew about the problem. I should be able to key in the channel from the remote but that option wasn't available. Instead, I had to scroll up and down. Annoying and a real time waster!
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Staff was wonderful! The breakfast was amazing, plentiful, and delicious I am very impressed. We will be back again!.
10,0 Excellent
Pros: It was close to the venue and easy acces to the expressway
10,0 Excellent
Pros: My husband told me if I get a survey make sure I fill it out. Everything was excellent. The room was nice&clean. A nice free breakfast. We couldn't believe how they were on top of refilling the breakfast stations. Very good service!
Cons: No.
8,8 Excellent
Pros: Honestly I would have given this hotel a 10 out of 10 but when I got the at 4 to check in I waited at the counter for about 10 min before someone came to check me in. It was empty not only in the parking lot but also in the hotel so would have been nice to get checked right in. Also the fan on the wall unit didn’t work as I sleep with a fan on and never pack one while traveling cause I know those work most of the time. Other then that the place is amazing. Very clean and even the room smelled amazing. I would recommend this hotel to everyone.
Cons: Everything
8,0 Excellent
Pros: We had a clean, comfortable room at a good price. It was very quiet, and we enjoyed making use of the facilities.
9,2 Excellent
Pros: breakfast was excellent. loved the suite and thought it was very quiet for it being such a busy area.
8,0 Excellent
Pros: the breakfast was excellent
Cons: we did not have a refrigartor or micrwave in our room
9,0 Excellent
Pros: Breakfast was excellant,cleanlinss,location.
Cons: Workers working on building at entrance.
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Was clean and morning breakfast had great choices. Beds were super comfy
Cons: No adjustable bathroom exhaust
7,5 Good
Cons: Easy access
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Super room. Very clean. Helpful staff. Comfortable bed. Linens and towels like new. Tasty breakfast with lots choices. Great location. Walked in with two bicycles and the staff didn’t blink an eye, like it happened every day. Who knows, maybe it do
Cons: All was well.
Overview Reviews
The area's #1 choice for business or pleasure; At the Fairfield Inn & Suites New Buffalo, you're our #1 priority. We promise you'll be satisfied, or we'll make it right. That's our commitment to you. Ask us about The Fairfield 100% Guarantee. Minutes away from Four Winds Casino, Lake Michigan, The vineyards of Harbor Country's Wine Trail, Warren Dunes State Park, and Lighthouse Place Premium Outlet Mall. A top rated Tripadvisor Hotel with perks like our free hot breakfast served daily, free WiFi, indoor pool and spa, fitness room, and meeting space in our private board room. Enjoy Four Winds Casino at your convenience with the free shuttle. Our guest rooms offer pillow-top mattresses, flat-screen TV's and all our suites are equipped with mini-fridges & microwaves. Whether you're travelling on business or to watch a breath taking sunset on Lake Michigan, the Fairfield Inn & Suites New Buffalo will make your stay right. That's our commitment to you.
3,0 Mediocre
Pros: It was quiet
Cons: Check in was at 3. At 4 our room wasnt ready. Returned at 5-still not ready. Came back 6:45-still wasn''t ready. A rude staff member told us the washer&dryer were slow & thats the way it was. Dirty towel with makeup on it in the bathroom. Unaccept
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Clean, comfortable, decent breakfast, very short drive to the four winds casino, or you can take the free shuttle bus there and back.
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Good size rooms and shuttle to and from casino.
7,5 Good
Pros: Clean and friendly staff
Cons: N/A nothing I didn't like
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Comfortable beds
Cons: No
10,0 Excellent
Pros: It was almost perfect. Staff very friendly and helpful.
Cons: T.V. was too small for room. This was THE only complaint of our stay. Will be back.
5,0 Okay
Cons: I dislike the overpowering musty smell in the room.
9,0 Excellent
Pros: The friendliness and accommodation by the marvelous staff!
Cons: The hairdryer needs to be replaced. :(
10,0 Excellent
Pros: Very clean
Cons: The price was ok, breakfast was only served till 9:30am.
7,0 Good
Pros: Location, price
Cons: Not really
10,0 Excellent
Pros: It was very clean and quiet.
Cons: The only issue we had was when we first arrived, there was no one at the front desk after waiting for over 10miN and ringing the bell several times. Again not a big issue.
9,0 Excellent
Pros: Price and location
Cons: There was a faint mildew smell