Mackinaw City hotels near Old Mackinac Point Lighthouse

Cons: The breakfast was a little limited in number of choices and quality. It was not bad, just not great.

Cons: We had wished that the hotel staff would have let us know that there was a very large senior tour during our stay. Only because the morning ended up being so crammed full of people trying to get breakfast and people waiting for the bus to load all of their luggage. We could have rearrangedone our schedule to try and avoid the mess.

Cons: I don't like that the pool wasn't accessible without a trip outside. It was still cool enough outside that that was a deterrent from bringing my young kids to the pool. The layout was only ok for things like the breakfast location and pool location; they very much have the appearance that they were add-ons after the original building was completed. I also had an issue with our toilet not wanting to flush. The maintenance response was quick and efficient, but later in our stay it appeared as though the fix wasn't complete.

Cons: A good deal on the internet meant a poor view out of our room--we looked out half to part of the parking lot (which always-every day- had laundry and carts and other maintenance items and half to the opposite side of the hallway. A good deal also meant lots of foot traffic by our door at all hours. Our mattress was very worn and needed to be turned or flipped or something. When we arrived, we encountered women from Haiti working at the front desk and they were still on the learning curve w/regard to checking people in. We were not given all the info we needed. Our key cards lost their programming to unlock our door twice during our three-night stay (annoying!).

Cons: My screen door was broken, which wouldn't be a big deal, but northern Michigan has SO MANY BUGS!!!

Cons: No complaints

Cons: disappointed to find out it would have been $30 (approximately) cheaper if I booked direct with the Hotel

Cons: Even though I had paid for the room when I booked it, I was charged again when I arrived. However, everything was straightened out when I left.

Cons: I had no stay at the Best Western! It was closed when I arrived at the INN about 6:30 PM. They were closed. A note on the door said to go to a different Inn. I did and paid a higher rate. KAYAK or BEST WESTERN I do not know but GOOE on you and Best Western!! A PHONE CALL TO LET ME KNOW WOULD KEPT ME FROM BEING SO PISSED.

Cons: The outdoor concourse was not clean, the drainage pipe on the beach was definitely an eye sore, pool hours are not very good as it needs to be open much earlier than 11am.

Cons: I have mobility problems and the elevator was a one end of the complex and our rooms were at the far end away from the elevator. There were ramps but I still had to walk too great a distance. I would not stay here again even if on the ground floor because I would have to go upstairs for breakfast with no direct elevator.

Cons: All the things that were broken in my room. My window couldn't be locked. The sheet had a stain on it. The plugs were broke and the water temp fluctuates wildly. Extreme hot and cold. If your looking for a cheep place to stay this is it but you definitely get what you pay for

Cons: To start the remote didn't work. They have a pool but no hot tub. Then to end our fifteen minute stay, the bed linen had softball size stains all over the bed. Obvious from the naked eye and being dark in the room. Front desk made me call hotels.Com to get my money back which happened then we went to a different hotel. So disgusting.

Cons: The room was a little small. The distance from the central part of town was a little awkward- a bit far to walk, too close to justify driving. Nothing major, however.

Cons: The location is at the end of the boardwalk. Not on beach where some of the website suggested

Cons: The water temperature in the shower kept fluctuating making for an interesting experience!

Cons: When we arrived we were informed that there was no room for us. My relatives still had a suite, but no room for us. They said they had tried to call us that morning, like it was our fault. We were moved down the road to another hotel which was nice, but away from family. Very disappointing.

Cons: Ensure rooms are accessible, and clean before offering them. And friendlier staff.

Cons: Staff had to be distracted away from magazine in order to check in (acted annoyed with our presence). Then as a second employee argued with first employee during our check-in we were completely ignored. Finally got room assignment and was placed directly next to open lobby area. Asked politely if they had a quieter room available and without looking up from the desk, we were told "we're full". We responded with "oh, you don't have any other rooms available?" And after an exaggerated sigh, told again "we're full". Very rude.

Cons: Bed was hard as a rock, pillows were tiny and flat, bathroom smelled, shower has a hole in the tub.

Cons: Older motel, felt and smelled like it needed updating. Kind of beat up, the entryways were dirty with cobwebs and bugs around. Room was just ok and didn't feel clean. Just old and overpriced for sure. Ok for a quick overnight stay but couldn't wait to move on.

Cons: Only one thing: We stayed for three days, two nights; and, in that time, saw a tissue on the floor next to a door on our floor that NEVER GOT PICKED UP! Come on, people. I noticed it. How could you NOT have noticed it ??

Cons: The bridge view/lake view was obstructed by the trees and hotel across the street. The "view" was the top of the bridge.

Cons: Breakfast is below average. The fruit looked old. Have a bagel or a waffle and go to Pancake Chef downtown. This place isn't bad, but like everything else in this area, way overpriced for what you get.

Cons: Our room was right between the pool and laundry facility. Both open until 10pm. Not great if you have young kids that you need to get to sleep. Faucet handle in tub was near falling off. Took about 10 minutes to get it to work right. The continental breakfast looked like they had the same food out all week.

Cons: The musty smell was unbearable!! Had to swat a few flies and spiders. The carpet turned my socks black. There were holes in the drapes. Unfriendly staff - Seems like they hated being there. After returning from the island we were tired and didn't want to deal with finding another place to stay. We payed in advance thru Kayak for two nights and ended up leaving the next morning and checked into a hotel across the bridge in St. Ignace which was about the same vintage but was very clean and had friendly helpful staff. Tried to get my money refunded for the unused day but couldn't find any staff so just left the key in the office key basket. I can't believe Kayak would even suggest this place. Next time I will always read the reviews before booking a hotel. Live and learn.

Cons: The housekeeping was terrible--potato chips left on a chair and nightstand, hand prints on the mirror, someone else's empty water bottle left behind the refrigerator (in plain sight), and we had to ask for more toilet paper, cups, and coffee packets when none were left by the housekeepers. It was obvious that they just didn't care.

Cons: Everything could have been better. Awful bed and pillows, scalding hot shower in ankle deep water. Just awful.

Cons: Cleanliness, room

Cons: Smelled funky. Carpet left our daughters feet black. Paper thin walls. Loud guests, we could hear neighbors and others in the parking lot all night. breakfast was sub par only 3 hot options and they ran out of food knowing the hotel was fully booked.

Cons: The mattress was the worst I’ve ever slept on, we got hardly any sleep it was so uncomfortable. The lampshades and heating/cooling unit needed a good dusting. The rest of the room was fairly clean, just outdated. But the mattress really ruined it for us. Can’t recommend this place at all.