Save up to 38%Compare multiple travel sites with one search.
Free to useThere are no hidden charges or fees
Filter your dealsFilter by car type, brand and more. Instantly customise your results.
Book with flexibilityUse our "free cancellation" filter for maximum flexibility at no extra cost.
Based on ratings and reviews from real users on KAYAK, the best car hire in Sanibel is Hertz (6,3, 60 reviews).
The average price of fuel in Sanibel is R61,90 per litre over the past 30 days. Filling up a tank of fuel costs between R743 and R990, depending on the car size.
Take a look at our extensive car hire location map to find the best car hire deals near you.
A compact or midsize car would be suitable when choosing car rentals in Sanibel, FL. The city is known for its beautiful beaches and nature preserves, and these cars offer the maneuverability and ease of parking required to navigate the island's narrow streets and crowded parking lots. Additionally, compact and midsize cars are fuel-efficient, which is advantageous for exploring the island without frequent refueling. With their comfortable interiors and smooth handling, these car types provide a pleasant driving experience while enjoying Sanibel's scenic beauty.
While driving car rentals in Sanibel, the speed limits will vary depending on the road you're driving on. For instance, Periwinkle Way, the main thoroughfare, has a speed limit of 35 mph. This road takes you through the heart of the city, passing by various shops and restaurants. When driving in residential areas such as Shell Island Road or Gulf Drive, the speed limit drops to 25 mph to ensure the safety of residents and pedestrians. Pay attention to these speed limit changes and always adhere to the posted signs to maintain a safe and respectful driving experience on Sanibel's roads.
The best places to park in Sanibel are the public parking lots near popular attractions and beaches. Some recommended parking locations include Lighthouse Beach Park, Tarpon Bay Road, and Bowman's Beach. The cost of parking in these public lots ranges from $5 to $10 per hour or a daily rate of $5 to $20, depending on the season. It's advisable to bring cash or have a credit card handy for payment. Be mindful of parking regulations and time limits to avoid fines or towing. Consider arriving early to secure a spot, especially during peak tourist seasons.
2 locations in Sanibel
Locations in Sanibel
15248 S Tamiami Trail S 150
+1 239 454 9750
8001 Hertz Drive
+1 239 390 8380
Filters
No reviews available
One location in Sanibel
Locations in Sanibel
15248 South Tamiami Trail
+1 239 454 9750
Filters
No reviews available
4 locations in Sanibel
Locations in Sanibel
1015 Periwinkle Way
+1 239 395 4571
15248 S Tamiami Trail S 150
+1 239 454 9750
20350 Summerlind Road
+1 239 214 7523
8001 Hertz Drive
+1 239 390 8380
Filters
Show reviews that mention
Reviews
6,0 Okay
Anonymous, Nov 2022
6,0 Okay
Anonymous, Jan 2022
4,0 Mediocre
Anonymous, May 2021
Cons:
When I booked online I had no idea that the location was NOT at the airport! They probably showed an address when I booked, but having never been there before I had no idea that that was not at the airport! The airport location said they could rent me another car, but it would be at a higher price,. But Hertz had already charged my credit cards and the airport location could not apply that amount to a new rental at the airport. I would have to pay the airport the full price and then try to get my money back from the other location. Then the other location said that if I took a cab out there to get the original car I could not drop it back off at the airport location when I returned home. I ended up doing $55 worth of cab fares both ways, not to mention the additional time delays. This will be my first and last time renting with Hertz.2,0 Poor
Anonymous, May 2021
Pros:
THE COMPANY YOU BOOKED ME WITH CLOSED AT NOON WHEN MY FLIGHT LANDED AT NOON AND THEY WOULD NOT WAIT FOR MECons:
SHOULD HAVE GONE WITH A COMPANY THAT COULD TELL TIME10,0 Wonderful
L, May 2021
Pros:
Pick up and drop off went smoothly.Cons:
I guess I wasn't paying attention that this Hertz rental was not an airport pickup, so we had to pay for a cab to get to the rental location in Fort Myers, not at the airport.10,0 Wonderful
Pamela, Apr 2021
Pros:
Great staff made the process easyCons:
Better if it were located at the airport or had a shuttle service3 locations in Sanibel
Locations in Sanibel
17811 San Carlos Blvd.
+1 239 466 8819
4806 Cape Coral Parkway
+1 239 549 3187
7191-1a Cypress Lake Drive
+1 239 466 8819
Filters
Show reviews that mention
Reviews
2,0 Poor
Devin, Mar 2024
Full-size
2,0 Poor
Anonymous, Sept 2020
Pros:
NothingCons:
The car chosen or anything comparable was not available. The gas was less than 1/4 tank. Car had cigarettes smell, and the car sensors kept going offPick-up location | Sanibel |
---|---|
Car types | |
Hire locations | 1 |
Airport locations | 0 |