Amara Cay Resort

80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States
+1 305 664 0073

Cheapest
rate per night

8,8

Excellent
based on 1 641 reviews
Amara Cay Resort - Islamorada, FL, United States
Check-in
-
Check-out
Compare vs KAYAK |

Provider Nightly total
TripAdvisor R2 843
Hotels.com R3 577
HotelTonight R3 904
TripAdvisor
Hotels.com
HotelTonight

Good to know

Distance to city centre 3,9 km
Location rating 9,3
Nearest airport Miami
Distance to airport 106,3 km

Rooms

Check-in
Check-out

Queen rooms

R5 314+

Bed type
Provider
Nightly base price
Queen bed
R5 314 per night
Queen bed
R5 812 per night
Queen bed
R6 101 per night
Queen bed
R6 354 per night
Queen bed
R6 537 per night
Queen bed
R6 602 per night
Queen bed
R6 602 per night
Queen bed
R6 992 per night
Queen bed
R7 355 per night
Queen bed
R9 081 per night
Queen bed
R10 071 per night
Queen bed
R11 291 per night

Double rooms

R7 269+

Bed type
Provider
Nightly base price
Unknown
R7 269 per night
King bed
R7 417 per night
King bed
R9 356 per night

Superior rooms

R2 843+

Bed type
Provider
Nightly base price
Unknown
R2 843 per night

Deluxe rooms

R3 820+

Bed type
Provider
Nightly base price
Unknown
R3 820 per night

King rooms

R4 508+

Bed type
Provider
Nightly base price
Unknown
R4 508 per night
Unknown
R4 985 per night
Unknown
R5 087 per night
King bed
R5 658 per night
Unknown
R5 871 per night
King bed
R6 021 per night
King bed
R6 973 per night
King bed
R7 184 per night
King bed
R7 260 per night

Standard rooms

R3 577+

Bed type
Provider
Nightly base price
King bed
R3 577 per night
King bed
R3 944 per night
King bed
R4 060 per night
King bed
R4 136 per night
King bed
R4 203 per night
King bed
R4 226 per night
Queen bed
R4 423 per night
King bed
R4 453 per night
Unknown
R4 556 per night
Unknown
R4 956 per night
Unknown
R4 956 per night
Unknown
R4 956 per night
Unknown
R5 224 per night
Unknown
R6 053 per night
Queen bed
R7 266 per night
King bed
R7 444 per night
Unknown
R8 598 per night
Queen bed
R9 104 per night

Reviews

Pros

Cons

Traveller rating

185
73
24
6
0

Time of year

Traveller type

Show reviews that mention

+
beautiful hotel in 12 reviews
bed was very comfortable in 10 reviews
friendly staff in 114 reviews
good food in 38 reviews
great view in 43 reviews
lighting in the bathroom in 25 reviews
location was great in 44 reviews
paddle boards in 20 reviews
pool area in 167 reviews
really enjoyed our stay in 3 reviews
restaurant service in 59 reviews
right on the beach in 59 reviews
room was nice in 20 reviews
sofa bed in 6 reviews
tiki bar in 71 reviews
towels at the pool in 103 reviews
view of the parking lot in 41 reviews
  • Good
    Mar 2020
    8,0

    Pool great Beach OK ,room liked wood flooring and bath

    TV awful no idea of channels .Picture fuzzy and too light .Just bad quality.Hotel check in lacking in warmth

  • Okay
    Mar 2020
    6,0

    The pool, tiki and beach area was wonderful! The lobby area very beautiful but didn't see anyone enjoying it. The fire bits were very nice but all the seats were always full so I didn't get a chance to enjoy!

    I would have liked more food options and the price was a bit much for the quality of the dishes. The nightstand and room was full of sand and I had to ask for it to be cleaned. The room was a bit worn out the desk chair wicker wrapping was coming apart and the mirror in the bathroom had a chip in on of the corners. I expected the rooms to be a bit more in the higher end for the price I paid.

  • Good
    Mar 2020
    7,0

    Located in the heart of Islamorada the hotel is in a good location. No real beach area to speak of other than a man-made barrier wall topped with sand.

    The front desk staff was rude. After my keys to the room wouldn't open the door, I was told that my money clip (non-magnetic) was the problem and informed to be more careful in handling the keys. The extra commentary was unnecessary and unappreciated when simply properly programming the card was all that was required. The additional "resort fees" seem extreme when none of the services were used. Minimal lighting in the room and the darkest bathroom that I've ever been to at a hotel.

  • Good
    Mar 2020
    8,0

    The setting is beautiful. The views are amazing. The bar is pretty.much on the beach and at night they have fire pits which makes it cosy and romantic. It is very easy to find on the highway but feels secluded. It is a great place to stop over on your way from miami to key west.

    The restaurant choices were poor and the breakfast was very expensive.

  • Good
    Feb 2020
    6,7

    Islamorada is close to many activities and the hotel is family friendly but far too over rated

    Bathroom was super tiny and we always had to ask for towels (3 or 4 towels are not enough for five people) One bed room had no window at all and once we came home late and found out that the top sheet of one bed was gone and we had to wait for it to be replaced Sofa bed in the living room was awful to sleep in

No reviews found. Try removing a filter, changing your search, or clear all to view reviews.

About

Overview

The Amara Cay Resort is a destination all its own, and sits right along the waterfront in beautiful Islamorada, Florida. This is part of the famous Florida Keys region and is half the way between Miami and Key West. Islamorada has long been known as the Fishing Capital of the World thanks to the calmness of its crystal clear waters, the surrounding coral reefs, and endless number of vendors and tour operators.

The location makes it perfect for individuals, couples or families and groups eager for a tropical getaway, and the amenities of the resort only enhance its value as a vacation destination. There is the fishing and the swimming in the surrounding waters, but there are also such niceties as free shuttle services, a private beach area, manicured gardens and grounds, pet-friendly policies, bike borrowing, a fitness center, swimming pool area, water sports, outdoor lounges, and Reelburger. The last is a fantastic burger restaurant on the premises and it stands near to the tiki bar where signature cocktails and tasty bites are always available.

The resort features guest rooms and more luxurious suites. All are furnished with premium bedding and linens, furnished balconies or terraces, work desks, entertainment systems with cable and movies, free Wi-Fi, hot beverage systems, large and private baths with signature toiletries, and more. The suites feature full kitchens with dining areas, and beach chairs and pool towels.

When seeking a one-stop location for a Florida Keys holiday, the Amara Cay Resort is sure to delight.

More

Features

Free parking
Free airport shuttle
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Pet friendly
Air conditioning

8,8 Excellent

based on 1 641 reviews

9,3

Location

9,1

Pool

6,1

Breakfast

3,5

Wellness Area

Things to know

  • Friendly service
  • Great view
  • Pleasant hotel grounds
  • Nice building

Check in

16:00

Check out

11:00

Cancellation/pre-payment

Policies vary by room type and provider.

Amenities

Fitness centre
Free Wi-Fi
Pets allowed on request. Charges may apply.
Disabled access
Business centre
Internet
Gift shop
Meeting/Banquet facilities
Bicycle hire
Outdoor pool
No smoking
Restaurant
Bar/Lounge
Express check out
Air-conditioned
24-hour front desk
Safe
Free parking
Private beach
Designated smoking area
Storage available
Terrace/Patio
EV charging station
Lift
Massage
Laundry facilities
Hairdryer
Wedding services
ATM on-site

FAQs when booking at Amara Cay Resort

Where is Amara Cay Resort located?

Amara Cay Resort is located at 80001 Overseas Highway, 3,9 km from the centre of Islamorada. Bud n' Mary's Dive Center is the closest landmark to Amara Cay Resort.

When is check-in time and check-out time at Amara Cay Resort?

Check-in time is 16:00 and check-out time is 11:00 at Amara Cay Resort.

Does Amara Cay Resort offer free Wi-Fi?

Yes, Amara Cay Resort offers free Wi-Fi.

Does Amara Cay Resort offer free parking?

Yes, Amara Cay Resort offers free parking.

Does Amara Cay Resort offer free airport shuttle service?

No, Amara Cay Resort does not offer free airport shuttle service.

How far is Amara Cay Resort from the airport?

Amara Cay Resort is 106,3 km from Miami. Amara Cay Resort is 117,8 km from Key West.

Can you bring pets to Amara Cay Resort?

Yes, Amara Cay Resort is a pet-friendly hotel.

Does Amara Cay Resort have a pool?

Yes, Amara Cay Resort has a pool on-site.

Photos

All photos (21)
Building (2)
Bedroom (2)
Bar (1)
Pool (4)

Location

Most popular landmarks

  • Bud n' Mary's Dive Center 336 m
  • Bud n' Mary's Fishing Marina 341 m
  • Hurricane Monument 2,7 km
  • Cheeca Lodge & Spa 2,8 km
  • History of Diving Museum 4,9 km
  • Theater of the Sea 7,3 km

Getting around

Miami 106,3 km
Key West 117,8 km
Miami 112,8 km
North Miami Beach Miami North 121,9 km

Nearby hotels

Closest

8,8 Excellent (393 reviews)
0,19 km
R3 235+
8,3 Excellent (1 045 reviews)
0,59 km
R5 166+
8,9 Excellent (768 reviews)
0,65 km
R3 896+

Cheapest

8,8 Excellent (393 reviews)
0,19 km
R3 235+
8,9 Excellent (768 reviews)
0,65 km
R3 896+
8,3 Excellent (1 045 reviews)
0,59 km
R5 166+

Most recommended

8,9 Excellent (768 reviews)
0,65 km
R3 896+
8,8 Excellent (393 reviews)
0,19 km
R3 235+
8,8 Excellent (1 748 reviews)
2,89 km
R5 392+